(A shorter version of this article appeared in Interesting Times #7, 2011)
No reflection on your sex life, but every night you go to bed
with a human, a monkey and a lizard.
These are gross
oversimplifications of the parts of your brain. Basically,
your rational ‘Human Brain’ is your neo-cortex. Your
social/emotional/troupe ‘Monkey Brain’ is your limbic
system. Your survival/autonomic functioning ‘Lizard Brain’
is your hind brain. Each of these
is necessary for human survival. They've been doing a great
job for millions of years in a world filled with things trying
to eat us.
We have survived these conditions by being social primates.
Being in a group and relying on each other is intrinsic to our
psychology. That brings us to our Monkey Brain. Our social behavior and
concerns are the realm of the Monkey Brain. This especially
means both the cause of conflict and our behavior during
such clashes. In the simplest of terms, the Lizard Brain
handles physical danger, the Monkey Brain handles social and
emotional 'threats.'
Which, unless you've been chased by a sabertooth tiger
lately, is the majority of what you're going to be
dealing with. So relax, the 'danger' is isn't real -- despite
what your Monkey is screaming at you.
Basically, when you are emotional and in an
argument (or fight), the Monkey Brain takes over. In this state,
the limbic system guides your
actions, feelings, words and even your perception of 'reality.'
Your brain is bathed in different chemicals and rational thought
is impaired.
(Think of a stoned Monkey driving the bus and you're not far
off.)
Here's a bit of a newsflash: As much as you might think the
fight is about you, it's about group dynamics, functionality and
staying together. Mostly what you are fighting for is how
things are going to be done around here.
This applies no matter how selfish, altruistic or
cooperative the participants' goals are. In order for a group to
survive there must be standards, rules, hierarchy, a division of
labor and resources and roles. How these are addressed,
who is doing what and is in what role is less important than
these issues are addressed.
That's what your Monkey is concerned about and that is what
it will be fighting for when it's driving the bus. Your
emotions, pride and your Monkey's 'psychic ability' (to know
exactly what the other Monkey meant by that -- remember
'perceived reality') are all distractions to keep
you from seeing this larger, underlying social primate agenda.
|
If you believe you are in control of yourself, you
won't feel the need to exercise self-control.
-- RM |
Many people are afraid of conflict. Personally, I put a greater emphasis on
the results. By this I mean both the result of engaging in
conflict and the result of not doing so. And, yes,
both have results. The reason I emphasize results is because
those are the consequences with which you have to live.
This especially
applies to any unacceptable results coming from not standing
up for yourself − because you tell yourself you’re afraid of
conflict.
But wait, doing
the ‘right thing’ and avoiding conflict shouldn’t have
negative consequences! Marc, what’s wrong with you for
saying that? Everyone knows conflict is bad! Look at the
results! Meetings with the HR (human resources) department
or boss at work, filing for divorce, filling out forms for a
new place to live because you split up, a new job
application, filling out incident reports for later use in
court, being arrested, going to trial, being in sued in
civil court.
All of these
are the results we supposedly fear from conflict. The
truth is, if conflict is mismanaged and allowed to escalate
out of control, these can be the results.
But is that always true? Does each and every conflict end up there?
No, and we know that.
At least our Human Brain does.
Much of what we claim ‘we fear’ is actually excuses. And those excuses hide
our real fears -- and motivations -- from us.
Such fears are
subconscious, primal, irrational and − if we’re honest with
ourselves − pretty stupid and selfish. Fears we want to
pretend we’re too good to have while they are
directing our
behavior.
What are these
fears? Fear of humiliation, shame, losing status or hurt
pride. Fear of how we will look to others and imaginary
consequences. In short, Monkey Brain fears.
These fears come from very primitive parts of our brains. Parts
we are not normally conscious of or aware how strongly they
direct our behavior. These fears seize control and plunge us
into discord faster than we can think.
But what’s most interesting is how − at the same time they put
us into dispute – they increase our loathing of conflict.
I mean, if we don’t fight, we’ll be humiliated. If we do
fight, we risk losing and being disgraced even more.
In
short, we’re hitting both the gas and the brake. Unfortunately,
we’re often a little slow on the brake, and the gas pedal wins.
When that happens, we find ourselves deep in clashes often
before we know what’s happening.
|
A good manager doesn't try to eliminate conflict; he tries to keep
it from wasting the energies of his people. If you're the boss and
your people fight you openly when they think that you are wrong -
that's healthy.
-- Robert Townsend |
In modern society, we’ve been conditioned to believe conflict is
bad. The result of this is we don’t know how to behave in
disputes anymore. This ignorance is hurting us.
First, we aren’t taught the ‘rules of conflict’ or why we need
to follow them.
Second, we’ve lost the knowledge how to safely engage in
disputes.
Third, because we aren’t taught how to cope with conflict, we’re
more likely to be traumatized by it. (Then this trauma is
pointed to as proof of how 'bad' conflict is.)
Fourth, our ‘civilized’ fears of discord allow us to be bullied
and intimidated by those who know how to turn our fears against
us.
Not a winning strategy, that.
So how do you manage conflict to get the best results?
We
can start by knowing the conflict cycle. Then it all becomes a
lot less scary. This is ‘scripted’ behavior that is oriented on
the Monkey’s agenda of keeping the troupe together and
functioning. (It’s a caveman thing). Remember, it is a squabble over how
the group is going to run. That’s what you’re fighting for.
Even better, once you understand the cycle, you’ll be far better
at ensuring any ‘results’ of conflict are positive.
Basically, a conflict inside a group can be understood as
"Bang! Bang! Kiss, kiss."

Starting at the bottom go up, clockwise. There everyone is just
tootling along, and everything is fine. Well, along comes a
problem. Instead of staying in our Human Brain and actually
fixing the problem, the Monkey Brain hijacks the issue and makes
it about our status, how someone treats us, our little duck
feelings getting hurt, our self-esteem or this person’s lack of
respect toward us.
In short, we personalize the problem. Once we do that, we’re in our
Monkey Brain and following its agenda.
From the moment we personalize
it, we are no longer trying to fix the actual problem, we are on
monkey scripts. To be more specific, we’re fighting over how
the group is going to be run.
Stop and think about that. It’s
both important and – no matter how much you think it’s about you
– it’s really about group dynamics. Try to think of a conflict
you were in with someone that wasn’t about those elements. (Go
ahead, I dare you.)
The next step is that things
heat up. Depending on how you’re socialized, this stage could be
yelling, screaming, waving your arms around and even threatening
to hit someone. Or it could be as subtle as your boss asking,
“Do you like working here?” No matter how it’s done, both
parties are sending messages of “don’t mess with me! See how
serious I am about this?”
Then comes the tipping point.
Now this could be as simple as you getting a visit from the
‘Angel of Duh!’ and realizing this issue isn’t worth
taking any farther. There are many ways this happens. The most
obvious is you don’t want the situation to go physical. In more
extreme cases, it could be someone knocking you on your ass with
a left hook. And you thinking, “I think he’s a little more
committed about this than I am.”
No matter how you get to the
‘tipping point,’ it’s you deciding you don’t want things to get
worse.
|
If an explosion is your
first indication that something is wrong, your warning signals
are set too high. Or they've been ignored until it's too late
-- MM |
When I ask, “Where do you think
things are most likely to go wrong with this process?” most
people answer on the upswing (Bang Bang part). The truth is,
most things get wonky on the part we’re now heading into (Kiss
Kiss).
The use of the term
‘submission/dominance signal’ can rub people the wrong way.
Well, tough. If we’re talking about
- an issue between you and
your boss (and you want to stay employed),
- if it’s between you
and a cop (and you don’t want to get arrested),
- if it’s between
you and a 250-pound biker (and you don’t want to get your ass
kicked) or
- if it’s between you and a teacher, etc., etc., …
then
dominance/submission are the proper terms.
If
it’s between you and your spouse, okay, it’s a slightly
different dynamic. Same goes between you and your friends and
other people you care about. But often, it really is about ‘do
it this way or else’ – even with your kids.
The dominance/submission stage
is easier to understand if we talk about it as: Throwing up your
hands and saying, “Alright, we’ll do it that way!” It’s actually
demonstrates you are no longer interested in taking the conflict
to a higher level. It signals you are now more interested in
moving into the conflict resolution stage.
This is different than the
tipping point because a decision made is not the same as
a decision communicated. This stage is about communication. This
is a subtle, but important, distinction. Because, as much as the
Monkey believes it’s psychic, it’s not. You do have to
communicate.
Another key element at this
stage is the ‘dominant’ showing it is safe for you to back down.
In fact, think of it as a deal he’s offering. Again,
communication.
This stage and the next are
where most situations go horribly wrong, but we’ll get to that
in a bit. Let’s keep on following the cycle to its conclusion
first.
Now
comes a critical juncture, ‘acceptance.’ Both of those signals
have been sent. But they have to be recognized, received and
accepted. In short, the terms and conditions have to be agreed
upon.
Why is this important? Because
they show that the conflict is functionally over. There is going
to be no more attacking one another, no more arguing and – most
important – that it is safe to quit for both parties.
Reconciliation is the real Kiss
Kiss part. Because up until then, we’ve been negotiating.
Reconciliation is where both parties must make gestures
to show no hard feelings. More specifically, they both
demonstrate that they’re still a group.
Not doing this will
leave the fight as unfinished business, and things will light up
again. This is where many 'bad' bosses fall down with conflict
management, but other people fail too.
Another subcategory of the
reconciliation stage is determining how the original problem
will be dealt with. This, even if it means the status quo
remains the same.
Only then do things return to
functional, and the group carries on.
I mentioned earlier that most
people screw up in the back half of the cycle. There are a lot
of ways. Often one mistake leads to another, and everyone heats
up again. Remember emotions are contagious, so too are mistakes.
First off, did you know that
most violence comes with instructions on how to avoid it?
It’s
true. So does most trouble incidentally, but it’s easier to see
this dynamic I’m talking about through the extreme of violence. For example,
when someone tells you to “shut up or I am going to kick your
ass,” he is not, I repeat NOT, asking for you to mention his
sexual practices with his mother.
But your Monkey Brain -- deeply
involved in threat displays and fixated on ‘winning’ -- will
tell you ignoring the instructions is the ‘right thing’ to do.
That excited, psychic Monkey has a hard time following any directions
except its own. It’s not going to let that other monkey tell it
what to do! Shut up? HA! I’ll show him by mentioning his
testicles on his mother’s chin!
Then it will blame the other
person for becoming more aggressive. In case you haven’t
guessed, the Monkey is real good at self-justifying its bad
behavior. But it’s even better at stirring things up and then
bailing out on you -- leaving you to deal with the negative
results. Keep that in mind next time you’re thinking about
mentioning someone’s mother during a fracas or getting in that
last dig.
When it comes to avoiding
violence, you really need to start listening, instead of
letting your Monkey tell you that you HAVE to do the direct
opposite. The Monkey not only makes us deaf, but goads us on out
of emotion, pride, anger, revenge and the insidious desire to
‘win.’
That’s really the big problem.
Just because you’ve passed the
tipping point (where you’ve decided you don’t want to keep
escalating up to violence), doesn’t mean your Monkey has
given up.
Read that again, it's that important.
If you have an overwhelming urge to ‘win,’ that’s
your Monkey. It will keep your mouth going aggressively long
after you should be on the resolution part of the cycle. And that’s where the back end of
the cycle often goes sideways.
It’s important here to mention something else. Of all human
behavior that can elicit negative responses, betrayal will get
you punished the worst. Keep that in mind. Because when you
break this cycle, the kneejerk response by most people is to
consider it betrayal.
When someone is offering you the
opportunity to safely back off from a battle, he or she is
taking a chance.
By sending the submission signal, you indicate
you aren’t willing to take it physical. Realistically, what you
are saying is you won’t 'attack' any more. They, in turn, ease off
the throttle, too. Think of this as lowering their guard in the
name of peace, a sign of trust. That's the chance they're
taking. In the process, they’re saying
they’ll stop attacking, too.
If you sucker punch them, it’s a
betrayal.
It’s easier to understand this
behavior in physical terms, but it happens verbally and
emotionally all the time. Someone just has to get that
last zing in to ‘even the score.’ It not only hurts and is a
betrayal, but your attack will cause the situation to explode
again.
That same Monkey, who got you
into the conflict, can make it much worse for you if you
allow it to keep going after the tipping point. If, after you
decide you aren’t willing to go physical (tipping point), but
still verbally attack during the cool down phase, it will be
seen – by the other person’s Monkey -- as a betrayal.
And, rightfully so, it will be
treated as such.
In what should be the calm down,
reconciliation stage, some people ‘need’ to get the last word,
throw a final insult, voice a parting shot, get in those snide,
contemptuous and sniping comments or – in a less obvious example
– still justify ‘why they were right in what they did.’
ALL
of these indicate the Monkey is still driving the bus.
That person is not only violating the conflict cycle, but his
Monkey is still on the fight.
Worse, they are telling the
other person’s Monkey that the issue isn’t settled and that they
will be a problem in the future. That’s because a pissed off
Monkey is an untrustworthy Monkey. This fight isn’t over, and it
will come back at you again. Is it any wonder this kind
of behavior elicits such a negative and extreme response?
Like I said, it’s easier to
explain this in terms of physical violence, but it also applies
to work and relationships. It is knowing when to tell your
Monkey to back off before you get fired or do irreparable damage
to your relationship. More than that, it's being able to
actually do it
Most people think it’s the fear
of punishment that keeps them from backing down. There’s some
validity to that. The truth is there are lots of people who
don’t know how to ‘win’ graciously. Such people break the rules
of the conflict cycle by demanding punishment and penance from
those who have dared challenge them.
The people who fear punishment
the most are the ones who are most likely to make it a
self-fulfilling prophecy.
This comes back to the betrayal
issue. Realistically, it wasn’t until that last dig they had
to throw in to ‘even the score’ that the other Monkey decided to
punish them.
In the thousands of conflicts I’ve been involved in
and witnessed, overwhelmingly this betrayal of the script is
what provokes retribution. Someone taking your submission as a
green light to punish is more the minority. Someone sending
a submission signal and then betraying the cycle with a last dig
to ‘even the score’ is far, far more common.
|
Fear not those who argue,
but those who dodge
-- Dale Carnegie |
I should also tell you about a
common misunderstanding during this process.
That is the perception if the
dominant starts huffing and puffing about having been challenged
he’s going to try to punish you. It looks like he might attack
again, but odds are he won’t. Think of a gorilla beating his
chest and making a lot of noise to prove what a stud he is.
Also, don’t be confused by the gender reference, women do this
chest beating, too.
There will usually be some
chest thumping by the dominant. Mostly it’s a matter of style.
Some are loud and obvious, others aren’t
Having said that, there’s a fine
line between chest thumping and being overly aggressive. And it
is a line a lot of inexperienced people cross.
If you have someone, who is
already concerned about punishment for having dared to challenge
you, and you get all big, bad and threatening, they have no
reason to back off. It’s not safe for them to do so. If they
feel threatened by too big a dominance display, they’ll go on
the attack again. This is another way things can light up again.
The back end of the conflict
cycle is a delicate process. And delicate process and pissed off
Monkeys don’t really make a winning combination. It takes a
mature person to take control of his or her Monkey and guide the
cycle to completion. This includes knowing when to ignore little
mistakes, like snide comments (meant to sooth that person’s
bruised ego), and ham handed, verbal dominance displays. When
the process is correctly guided, the conflict is resolved and
everyone is happy.
I’d like to point out another
way things can go wrong. I have a saying: If there are seven
stages to a conflict, a bad boss only does five of them.
Reconciliation is important
because -- if you don’t complete the cycle with make up gestures
and communication that things are alright between you – discord
will begin anew. And it usually will be with more vengeance and
outrage because someone violated the cycle and betrayed you. You
don’t slap away the hand that is offering the peace laurel.
Even chimpanzees, after a fight,
will bring each other gifts, groom each other and comfort one
another to show that everything is okay. But many people, who
apparently aren’t smarter than chimps, will insist on pride,
continued outrage and the belief that it is the OTHER Monkey who
was in the wrong. It’s up to the other monkey to make up with
them (read grovel)
This is a great way to lose
friends, lose jobs, estrange yourself from family and, of
course, get divorced. Those nasty ‘results’ kind of things.
|
The worst lies are the lies we tell ourselves. We live in denial of
what we do, even what we think. We do this because we're afraid. We
fear we will not find love, and when we find it we fear we'll lose
it. We fear that if we do not have love we will be unhappy.
-- Richard Bach |
There is one more thing I have to mention. There’s a lot of
confusion about this cycle in the modern world. We’ve been
taught that conflict is taboo. In fact, it’s to this century
what sex was to the 1950s – NICE people don’t talk about it or
admit they do it.
We’re social primates, so, like
sex, conflict is part of life. Like it or not, we’re going to
have disputes with those people in our lives as we hash out the
group dynamics. You can use these guidelines to become better at
handling conflict and less fearful about it.
Or you can keep on letting your
Monkey dig you deeper and deeper into conflict and have to face
the consequences. If you really want things to get ugly, don’t
follow this pattern, especially at work, in your relationships
or with your family.
Who do you want controlling your
life, you or your Monkey?
Marc
MacYoung and Rory Miller are the cofounders of Conflict
Communications (www.conflictcommunications.com)
©2011
Marc MacYoung All rights reserved